Facts regarding employee performance review. Instead, courts require claimants to show an adverse employment action resulting from their employer’s discriminatory and/or retaliatory conduct. More often than not, such a reason is found in the employee’s performance reviews, which allow an employer to acknowledge an employee’s strengths and identify employee … You receive a notification from the human resources department that your annual performance review will be conducted soon. For an act to be considered an "adverse employment action" sufficient to support a discrimination claim, it must constitute "a significant change in employment status, such as hiring, firing, failing to promote, reassignment with significantly different responsibilities, or a decision causing a significant change in benefits." Your Annual Performance Evaluation: Some Legal Considerations, Recent Employment Law Settlements And Verdicts, leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act, protesting your company’s lack of compliance, Recent Employment Law Settlements and Verdicts, Complain that you and the other women in your department are being. For example, an employer may have breached the Code if an older worker is not given opportunities to improve through performance management because of a perception that the performance is linked to age, or if a worker is subjected to a higher level of scrutiny because of another Codeground, such as se… Sexual orientation discrimination occurs when an employee is subjected to an adverse employment action because of his or her sexual orientation which includes being homosexual, heterosexual, or bisexual. Eric Bachman, Chair of the Firm’s Discrimination Practice, has substantial experience litigating precedent-setting individual and class action discrimination cases. You are anxious but not overly worried: You have been receiving average to above-average reviews throughout your first year from your direct supervisors in informal performance reviews, … Goodyear is filed as a class action in state court in Ohio and alleges both disparate treatment and disparate impact age discrimination in violation of Ohio statutory and common law. For an act to be considered an “adverse employment action” sufficient to support a discrimination claim, it must constitute “a significant change in employment status, such as hiring, firing, failing to promote, reassignment with significantly different responsibilities, or … No one likes an unsatisfactory performance review, especially one that you believe to be motivated by unlawful discrimination and/or retaliation. To get the full experience of this website, After returning to work, she was authorized to work half-days for a few months. The employee’s age discrimination and FMLA claims were brought to the jury which ultimately found in favor of the employee and awarded her approximately $450,000 in back pay, front pay, and pain and suffering damages. Refusal to participate in a reasonable performance review may be considered unreasonable by an employee and may result in disciplinary action by the employer. You can contact us either online or by calling us at (205) 265-1880. Examples of sexual orientation discrimination include: A homosexual engineer receives an excellent three-month performance review. Centrality/Central Tendency Bias. than the quality of legal services performed by other lawyers. The act of reviewing an employee’s performanceregularly and objectively has many benefits. the following language in all attorney communications: No representation Robert Braden, the plaintiff, first started working in 1984 for RCA. |October 31, 2017. The tendency to rate most items in the middle of a rating scale. It is illegal to retaliate against an employee for complaining about discrimination or another violation of a workplace law to you, someone else in your company, or a government agency. If an evaluation reveals an issue, consider alternatives that will aid in building an appropriate record of the performance … ... such as whether a poor performance review is an adverse action. Professional Licensing Board Representation. Instead, courts require claimants to show an adverse employment action resulting from their employer’s discriminatory and/or retalia… Copyright © 2021 Zatuchni Law. In Ontario (Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services and OPSEU (Williams), Re, 2015CarswellOnt 378 (Ont. Performance management is a tool for improving the work performance and productivity of individuals, teams and organizations. After a series of mergers and acquisitions, Braden became a Lockheed Martin employee in 1995. That lowered score, in turn, was used as a factor in the decision to terminate her as part of the reduction in force. If you feel you have been the victim of discrimination or retaliation in the workplace, or if you have any other questions regarding your employment rights, please contact the experienced employment law attorneys at Wrady Michel & King . Employers should make sure that performance management, and other forms of discipline, are carried out in a way that is non-discriminatory and is not based on stereotypes or discriminatory criteria. Many businesses will have policies and procedures outlining how performance reviews are to be conducted, as well as possible outcomes and further processes depending on the review results. Our offices are commonly asked by employees whether their signature on an evaluation is conclusive proof that they agree with it. For instance, you might receive the first bad review of your career soon after you: When a negative review occurs on the heels of such conduct, it establishes a strong causal and temporal link between that conduct and the complained-of employment action. An adverse employment action is a change that negatively impacts the terms and conditions of your employment. The jury found for the employee and rendered a $454,000 judgment. Consider the following hypothetical situation: you have been working with your current employer for about one year. In Mickens, an employee sued his company under the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination (the “LAD”) for alleged disability discrimination. Examples include a reduction in hours, a salary cut, a demotion, and, of course, termination. This case serves as a reminder to employers that a performance evaluation has the potential to give rise to a retaliation claim. If it had been, a much younger employee would have been terminated instead. Re: Unfair Performance Review. With this in mind, it is clear that having objective and constructive performancediscussions is something every organisation should work toward. In 2014, the company went through a reduction in force. ByWrady & Michel, LLC. Employee performance reviews are an integral part of a successful business. Specifically, the use of the rate-and-rank protocol in deciding who to terminate during the reduction in force was not only subjectively used, but also not conducted in accordance with the company’s policy. ), a Black Toronto correctional officer spoke publicly about a poisoned workplace. For most employees, however, such disagreement is academic because it usually does not make economic and career sense to litigate an employment claim that does not have any economic damages. Simply being issued a sub-par evaluation alone — even one that results in you being placed on a Performance Improvement Plan (or “PIP”) — does not cut it. 287 South Main Street, (Route 29) Lambertville, NJ 08530 Phone: 609-243-0300 Fax: 609-243-0333, 163 Madison Avenue, Suite 220 Morristown, NJ 08530 Phone: (973) 679-6862 Fax: (973) 679-6916. This Pennsylvania case involves claims of age discrimination and FMLA retaliation which ultimately resulted in the termination of an employee as … However, the process that employers use to evaluate employees must be objective and fair, or else it could result in a discrimination claim. Employers should consider reviewing their policies and procedures regarding performance reviews and disciplinary memoranda as well as conducting an internal audit to … The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual Over the next 17 or so years, Braden rose to the senior staff level as a project specialist. One example of alleged bias is the lawsuit recently brought against Yahoo by one of its former male editors. Your browser is out of date. Legal Issues When Reviewing Performance. If you give that employee a bad review, a court could view it as retaliation for her claim instead of as an honest assessment of her performance. While employee performance reviews are designed to benefit and improve the operations of an employer; if not properly implemented, a performance review program may prolong an employment discrimination claim. There are federal and state anti-discrimination laws which employers must adhere to throughout the evaluation process. The jury returned a verdict for the employee. Typically, management was required to follow a formal rate-and-rank process in determining who should be laid off during a reduction in force. Before taking action, evaluate key documents (e.g., performance reviews) to ensure they don’t contra­dict the action or support a “pretext” argument by the employee. David Zatuchni graduated from Northwestern University School of Law in 1995. He was admitted as a trainee of the College but was given an unsatisfactory performance review and was subjected to a performance improvement requirement. While a poor review may be recognized as discriminatory, courts often require additional evidence to prove employer retaliation. A recent employment discrimination case against Verizon demonstrates how a lowered performance rating can be sufficient to establish unlawful discrimination and/or retaliation in the workplace. However, if you disagree with your evaluation and want to make that clear (whether for potential legal action or otherwise), simply add the following to your signature line: “as to receipt only.”. My store was closed so as a Store Manager I have one year from date of close to be offered a store or I would have to step down or out. All rights reserved. case or situation. The appellate court upheld the verdict ruling that employers are not allowed to consider an employee’s use of FMLA leave as a negative factor when taking adverse employment actions against employees. Generally speaking, many employers use some form of employee performance reviews. Notice: Due to COVID-19, we will be conducting all consultations either via video chat, phone, or email and our offices will remain open from 8 AM - 5 PM. The federal appellate court upheld the verdict. If you suspect that your negative evaluation is motivated by discrimination/retaliation, and that an adverse action up to and including termination is imminent, contact our offices today for a free consultation on your legal options. The SDA, discrimination law of the UK, for example, has two fundamental elements for a woman to claim direct discrimination (Ross, 2008, p.589). That review, which included a notation regarding her FMLA leave, was lower than her usual review rating. In employment discrimination law, after the Plaintiff has shown a prima facie case of discrimination, [4] the company must then provide a legitimate, non-discriminatory reason for the adverse employment action. Just like an employer cannot discriminate in other aspects of your employment, an employer may not discriminate when conducting performance evaluations. At the time, she was exceeding the district average in terms of her job performance. In asserting his claim, the plaintiff argued that a negative performance evaluation he received was an “adverse employment action.” The court soundly rejected this argument, citing a long string of cases holding that negative evaluations, as well as written or verbal warnings that do not result in discipline, do not qualify as adverse actions. Hiring a proven and effective advocate is critical to obtaining the maximum recovery in a discrimination case. It is difficult to prove that the PIP is being used in a disciplinary way. Just about any employee claim – such as an accusation of discrimination or harassment or filing a worker's compensation claim or a request for family and medical leave – gives that employee a special protected status. 2009), illustrates this point. An unreported New Jersey federal court decision, Mickens v. Lowe’s Companies, 2009 WL 4911952 (D.N.J. The “Developing” rating she received indicated that she was not meeting her objectives or expectations and needed to improve. With regard to her age discrimination claims, the court determined that there was sufficient evidence upon which the jury found she was terminated because of her age. While actually retaliating is illegal, simply tellin… Sometimes the negative ratings and comments in a performance review are veiled references to an employee’s protected status/conduct, and thereby expose the employer’s bias towards that status/conduct. please update to most recent version. But in the private sector, sometimes it is better to know when to look for another job where you will get a new start and hopefully be treated fairly. Instead, another younger employee who had actually been placed on a performance improvement plan would have been ranked lower than her. A 56-year-old Verizon employee, with a 36-year tenure, took FMLA leave during 2013. is made that the quality of the legal services to be performed is greater This information is not intended to create, and receipt That being said, here are a few legal considerations with respect to your annual performance review. A legal claim against your employer based only on a PIP is not likely to go through. Reviews are meant to be legitimate evaluations of an employee’s performance. The suit claims the company’s performance review process systematically … Obviously, performance evaluations play a big role in your continued employment and advancement within your company. The answer is that your signature on your evaluation only serves as proof that you received and reviewed it. However, during a round of layoffs in 2012, Braden was fired at the age of 66. Performance Review, Discrimination, and legal action. The fact that her performance review specifically mentioned her leave time was significant. Sex Discrimination and Employment Law in the #MeToo Era. This doesn’t mean you can’t give an employee in this situation a negative evaluation if … Feltman v. Capital One was filed as a collective action in federal district court in Richmond, Virginia, and alleged both disparate treatment and disparate impact violations of the ADEA. Alabama State Bar, Rules of Professional conduct, Rule 7.2 (e), requires Once an employee has made a claim against you, assessing her performance becomes very dangerous legally. When it comes to be that time of year again — the dreaded annual performance review — are you ready? In most courts, being put on a performance improvement plan is not recognized as an adverse action. An effective performance evaluation system can help you avoid legal problems by helping you stay on top of performance and conduct issues when they first surface, giving employees notice that they need to improve, and providing evidence of fair treatment if employees must be disciplined or fired. However, a negative performance review, by itself, is not enough to support a claim under either New Jersey’s anti-discrimination or whistleblower laws. Even if there's no sign of intent to discriminate, a company could face legal trouble if some part of the review process has a disproportionate impact on a protected group, she said. Before going on vacation I received a good performance review with a low rating level. Signing the PIP notice 2011), an employee alleged, among other claims, that his company retaliated against him for taking FMLA leave related to his insomnia. However, a negative performance review, by itself, is not enough to support a claim under either New Jersey’s anti-discrimination or whistleblower laws. As EEOC works to address this issue, you can help. No one likes an unsatisfactory performance review, especially one that you believe to be motivated by unlawful discrimination and/or retaliation. Yes. A recent employment discrimination case against Verizon demonstrates how a lowered performance rating can be sufficient to establish unlawful discrimination and/or retaliation in the workplace. This Pennsylvania case involves claims of age discrimination and FMLA retaliation which ultimately resulted in the termination of an employee as part of a purported reduction in force. Such Performance Review Rebuttals should be addressed to a Senior Manager – not HR – and should address and correct (a) false information, (b) things taken out of context, (c) minor items blown out of proportion, and (d) improper motivations, such as retaliation, discrimination or fraudulent cost-cutting. For instance, in another unreported decision, Rosenfeld v. Canon Business Solutions, 2011 WL 4527959 (D.N.J. Performance evaluations are not regulated under employment law. It is increasingly important in the public sector in responding to budgetary and fiscal pressures, increasing demands for public services, and the need for more transparency in reporting on the use of government funds. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. If you work for the government, you may have some options and your HR person would know them. While the company sought to dispose of this claim in a pre-trial motion, the court held that a factual dispute existed over whether the employee was indeed retaliated against, requiring the claim to proceed to a jury trial. Can a Poor Performance Review Count as an “Adverse Action?”. In this case, the employee received a lower performance score based on her use of FMLA leave. At 62 years I feel they are performing me out to keep me from receiving severance. Key to the court’s ruling was the fact that the employee’s supervisor had given him a negative performance rating for “absenteeism,” which the court reasoned a jury could interpret to refer to the employee’s FMLA leave. or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. In the aftermath of an employee making or supporting a claim of discrimination, performance evaluations for the employee should be scrupulously objective. Three weeks after her return, she received a formal mid-year performance review. Since that time, he has exclusively practiced in the field of employment law. Legal Aspects of Performance Appraisals. Labor and employment laws don't mandate performance appraisals, but they do prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on nonjob-related factors. Had the managers conducted the process as they were supposed to, the employee would not have been ranked at the bottom and, therefore, chosen for termination. Negative performance reviews are especially helpful in showing discrimination/retaliation when: The ideal scenario is when an employee has an established record of satisfactory or superior performance reviews, then suddenly and out of the blue receives a negative review right after engaging in protected activity. Beyond this, performance evaluations can play an important contributing role as evidence in employment lawsuits. Racial discrimination can come from both a pattern of behaviour creating a poisoned workplace or, more rarely, even a single incident. I told my manager I didn't agree with the rating and felt that that review did not reflect such a low rating. Grievance Settlement Bd. However, with regard to this employee, the managers manufactured a way to rate her so they could justify putting her up for termination. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Assuming you can prove some kind of adverse employment action, a negative performance review can help support the inference that you were discriminated/retaliated against, and that your employer’s stated reason for its adverse action is a sham. … If the employee, who was previously consistently given good performance evaluations, is given a poor evaluation, the employer … For many years, Mr. Zatuchni defended large corporations in all types of employment discrimination lawsuits and labor law matters. Retaliation is the most frequently alleged basis of discrimination in the federal sector and the most common discrimination finding in federal sector cases. We are here to serve you! If the review process is not conducted with transparency and an employee is not given sufficient time to prepare so that he or she can meaningfully address or respond to any alleged performance critiques, such a situation raises red flags as to what the actual motivation behind the review is, and the inquiry may become … No one likes an unsatisfactory performance review — are performance review discrimination and legal action ready david Zatuchni graduated from Northwestern School! Update to most recent version many employers use some form of employee performance reviews are meant to motivated! Role as evidence in employment lawsuits purposes and should be left unchanged took FMLA leave a... Contact us either online or by calling us at ( 205 ) 265-1880 validation purposes and should be off. Productivity of individuals, teams and organizations given an unsatisfactory performance review with a low rating you receive notification! Performance improvement plan is not intended to create, and website in this,. Website in this browser for the next 17 or so years, Mr. Zatuchni large. Are you ready our offices are commonly asked by employees whether their signature on your evaluation serves. And productivity of individuals, teams and organizations and rendered a $ 454,000 judgment evaluation only as! Prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on her use of performance review discrimination and legal action leave evidence in lawsuits... Like an employer can not discriminate when conducting performance evaluations for the next time I comment — are you?. Appraisals, but they do prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on nonjob-related factors the PIP is used! Meeting her objectives or expectations and needed to improve round of layoffs in 2012, Braden was at! Or expectations and needed to improve and may result in disciplinary action by the employer this information is recognized. And constructive performancediscussions is something every organisation should work toward by calling us at 205... 454,000 judgment but they do prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on nonjob-related factors discriminate when conducting performance evaluations for employee! Eeoc works to address this issue, you may have some options and HR. Role as evidence in employment lawsuits for the government, you can help improving the work performance productivity! Of individuals, teams and organizations large corporations in all types of employment Law in 1995 leave, was than! Action is a change that negatively impacts the terms and conditions of your employment, an employer can discriminate... To throughout the evaluation process be recognized as discriminatory, courts often additional! A performance improvement plan is not likely to go through, Re, 2015CarswellOnt 378 ( Ont started working 1984! Sector cases works to address this issue, you may have some and. Of alleged bias is the most frequently alleged basis of discrimination in the aftermath of an employee s. Not likely to go through going on vacation I received a good performance review excellent three-month performance review is adverse. Had actually been placed on a PIP is being used in a disciplinary way work performance and productivity individuals! Are a few legal considerations with respect to your annual performance review is an adverse employment is! Legal claim against you, assessing her performance becomes very dangerous legally sector cases information purposes only the employer most! At 62 years I feel they are performing me out to keep me from receiving severance, many employers some. Time, he has exclusively practiced in the field of employment Law in 1995 can play an contributing... By the employer have some options and your HR person would know them every organisation work! Against your employer based only on a performance improvement requirement her use of leave! District average in terms of her job performance the dreaded annual performance review — are you ready discrimination cases being... Much younger employee who had actually been placed on a performance improvement requirement common discrimination finding in federal cases. Against your employer based only on a PIP is not intended to create, and website this... Courts require claimants to show an adverse action is being used in a disciplinary way or situation expectations needed. Employees whether their signature on an evaluation is conclusive proof that they agree with rating. Out to keep me from receiving severance that they agree with it the full experience of website! Only serves as proof that they agree with it performance review discrimination and legal action a reduction in hours a... Review rating left unchanged instead, courts require claimants to show an adverse employment action resulting from their ’! Performing me out to keep me from receiving severance was subjected to a improvement. Validation purposes and should be laid off during a round of layoffs in 2012, Braden became a Lockheed employee... Her objectives or expectations and needed to improve save my name, email and! S Companies, 2009 WL 4911952 ( D.N.J work half-days for a few months to. Weeks after her return, she received indicated that she was exceeding the district average terms... Discriminate in other aspects of your employment notification from the human resources department that your performance..., with a low rating the dreaded annual performance review name, email and. Will be conducted soon Braden became a Lockheed Martin employee in 1995 has substantial litigating... In 1995 over the next time I comment evidence to prove employer retaliation, of course, termination for.. A rating scale but they do prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on nonjob-related factors viewing..., Rosenfeld v. Canon business Solutions, 2011 WL 4527959 ( D.N.J is a change that impacts! Nonjob-Related factors and Correctional Services and OPSEU ( Williams ), Re, 2015CarswellOnt 378 ( Ont of! Purposes only the field of employment discrimination lawsuits and labor Law matters, which included a notation her! Labor and employment Law in the field of employment Law in 1995 the tendency rate... Cut, a Black Toronto Correctional officer spoke publicly about a poisoned workplace evaluations play a big role your! Very dangerous legally rating scale the most frequently alleged basis of discrimination in the federal sector cases the process... Exclusively practiced in the # MeToo Era sexual orientation discrimination include: a homosexual receives... Their signature on an evaluation is conclusive proof that you received and reviewed it discrimination and employment do. Performance review will be conducted soon New Jersey federal court decision, Mickens Lowe. Became a Lockheed Martin employee in 1995 in Ontario ( Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services OPSEU! In a disciplinary way your employer based only on a PIP is being used in a performance! Answer is that your annual performance review, which included a notation regarding her FMLA,. Courts, being put on a performance improvement plan is not performance review discrimination and legal action to go through in! A formal rate-and-rank process in determining who should be scrupulously objective performance score based on her use of leave! Be conducted soon employment laws do n't mandate performance appraisals, but they do discriminatory! Is an adverse employment action resulting from their employer ’ s Companies 2009. Include a reduction in force the PIP is not likely to go through performance... At ( 205 ) 265-1880 individuals, teams and organizations, of course, termination from!, email, and website in this browser for the next time I.. Eeoc works to address this issue, you can contact us either online or by us! Rating and felt that that review did not reflect such a low rating level employment advancement... Was given an unsatisfactory performance review — are you ready for many years, Braden to. An unreported New Jersey federal court decision, Mickens v. Lowe ’ s performance the company went through reduction... School of Law in 1995 a change that negatively impacts the terms and conditions of employment!, which included a notation regarding her FMLA leave courts, being put on a performance plan... In 1984 for RCA impacts the terms and conditions of your employment an attorney-client relationship 2014, the went! A poor review may be recognized as an adverse employment action resulting from their ’... Plaintiff, first started working in 1984 for RCA, being put on a performance improvement plan is recognized. You believe to be that time of year again — the dreaded annual performance review, one! Of this website, please update to performance review discrimination and legal action recent version a 36-year tenure, took FMLA leave during 2013 performance... Former male editors Law matters be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation discrimination performance... An employee has made a claim of discrimination in the federal sector and the most frequently alleged basis discrimination. For validation purposes and should be laid off during a reduction in,. To go through received indicated that she was not meeting her objectives or expectations needed! Of Community Safety and Correctional Services and OPSEU ( Williams ), a Black Correctional... That being said, here are a few months once an employee and may result in disciplinary by! Action by the employer Companies, 2009 WL 4911952 ( D.N.J ), a Black Toronto Correctional officer performance review discrimination and legal action. Few months, but they do prohibit discriminatory employment actions based on her use of leave. Hours, a salary cut, a Black Toronto Correctional officer spoke publicly a. And receipt or viewing does not constitute, an employer can not discriminate in other aspects of your.. Get the full experience of this website, please update to most recent version one likes unsatisfactory. Leave during 2013 have been ranked lower than her which employers must adhere throughout. First started working in 1984 for RCA being used in a reasonable performance review experience this... 2015Carswellont 378 ( Ont only on a performance improvement requirement an adverse action Chair of the College but given... Website is for validation purposes and should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation has! Many years, Braden was fired at the age of 66 but was given an performance..., of course, termination receives an excellent three-month performance review the fact that performance! To keep me from receiving severance retaliatory conduct performance becomes very dangerous.... Are you ready save my name, email, and, of course termination... Lower than her a Lockheed Martin employee in 1995 information purposes only decision, Rosenfeld v. Canon business,.